When AI Agents buy insurance, what happens to customer trust?

Picture of Kane Simms
Kane Simms

If an AI agent chooses your insurance, what makes you trust the insurer when you need to claim?

More ways to listen and watch

About this episode

At CCW Europe in Amsterdam, I spoke with Bogdan Tancic, Director of Customer Experience at Lemonade, about trust, AI and the changing insurance customer journey.

Bogdan explains how Lemonade uses AI across onboarding, pricing, underwriting and fraud detection. We discuss how trust is earned through small interactions, why accurate APIs matter when personal agents research products, and what happens after the purchase when a customer needs help.

The conversation considers an emerging shift towards personal AI agents. Bogdan separates the potential changes in distribution from the continuing importance of service, reassurance and the human experience of making a claim.

Guest

Bogdan Tancic

Director of Customer Experience at Lemonade

Timestamps

00:00|Meet Bogdan and Lemonade
00:38|An AI-native approach to insurance
01:32|How AI affects customer trust
03:52|AI across the insurance journey
04:42|Personal agents and insurance buying
07:57|How agents could change buying decisions
09:44|The human experience after the purchase
12:15|Retention, renewals and trust

Transcript

[2.26–16.40] Hi, so your conversations with Kane obviously. Kane’s going to introduce them in that camera.
[16.98–21.60] So we’ll start off by looking now and then when the conversation starts just talk to each other.
[21.96–27.24] If I move, ignore me, try not to follow me with your eyes. I might check that camera or do something.
[35.94–45.28] Hello, welcome back to VUX on the road here at CCW Europe in Amsterdam. I’m with Bogdan Tancic
[45.28–50.46] from Lemonade, Director of Customer Experience. Keen to get your thoughts on a bunch of things
[50.46–55.22] because I’ve been following Lemonade from afar for a long time and we kind of mentioned earlier
[55.22–62.64] on I’m sure that Lemonade was the brand that originally was pretty much only available to
[62.64–66.82] interact with via SMS or something like that. I don’t know how true that is. I’ll have to
[66.82–71.78] dig out the thing and find it out but essentially long history as a company of leveraging
[71.78–78.64] AI would you say? I would completely agree with that and if I may take you a step back there
[78.64–84.08] and ask you a question back. What’s your feeling about traditional insurance companies if you were
[84.80–89.86] comparing Lemonade with the others? Lemonade when you say is fairly new on the market
[89.86–94.70] comparing to the traditional insurance companies and it’s actually built on the premise of that
[94.70–99.50] insurance can be about trust and not the mistrust. There is this perception of people
[99.50–105.58] having insurance treating as a mistrust element with a lot of complexity and etc. Therefore
[105.58–111.02] Lemonade was actually built to disrupt that whole perception and making sure that technology
[111.02–117.14] can amplify that. So Lemonade was built I think more than 10 years ago to actually disrupt
[117.14–123.72] that original traditional insurance space around the technology. So it’s basically the AI
[123.72–130.68] native company which built the insurance around it. Interesting. So another question there
[130.68–137.16] that sort of stems from that is that today there is this kind of like almost like a tension
[137.16–142.54] when it comes to trust of AI because on the one hand you’ve got certain media outlets talking
[142.54–146.54] about it being a doomsday scenario a lot of the researchers from a lot of the frontier labs are
[146.54–151.04] talking about it could take over the world and annihilate humanity. At the same time those
[151.04–155.26] same people are also saying that it could be the best thing for humanity ever because we can
[155.26–160.46] cure all kind of diseases it’ll be really beneficial for us. So like the general public
[160.46–165.24] if I think about my mom for example are kind of in this weird position those that are not in
[165.24–168.78] the industry are in this kind of weird position where either AI is oh I don’t know about that
[168.78–174.56] or it’s kind of like positive. As a company that’s built on technology that’s infused with AI
[175.08–179.76] how do you handle that whole kind of trust question because the trust that you want
[179.76–184.86] to establish is built in those little tiny interactions that you have with customers over
[184.86–188.80] time. So is there anything you can share in terms of how do you go about building trust?
[189.38–193.12] Definitely and I think that’s going to become like even bigger topic in future and we can
[193.12–199.42] discuss more about that like trust is a big big factor of consumers that we have.
[200.36–206.34] Part of that is earning trust in a small points of interactions with customers right.
[206.82–212.34] One is whenever they need you so that you are there so that they can quickly and to the point
[212.34–217.86] resolve their issues that they have and I think you earn trust over time it’s not the
[217.86–222.28] thing that you get or lose basically you can lose it pretty pretty quickly and that’s a big
[222.28–227.18] thing right but like you earn it over time you’ll earn it at every point of interaction that you
[227.18–232.56] have from the moment you quote right eliminate we can talk about a little bit about how we leverage
[232.56–237.50] AI right from the moment you quote basically to get you the best pricing for the best coverage
[237.50–242.62] right that’s all powered by AI right and then the moment you’re on board right and then the
[242.62–247.42] most important part when you claim right when you’re actually there for the customer when
[247.42–251.74] they really need it that’s where you want to show that you can quickly resolve the problem for
[251.74–256.50] when they actually need you right and so those are the moments when you actually gain this trust
[256.50–262.48] and earn it with the customers that you have and AI definitely amplify amplifies that and gives
[262.48–268.04] you ability to be you know the most sincere the most accurate to to to the customers that they
[268.04–273.60] have nice can you share a little bit in terms of where you’re kind of leveraging AI and types
[273.60–277.36] of use cases that you’re that you have live and things like that yeah definitely I was
[277.36–282.02] mentioning about you know starting with the onboarding right we have AI walking you to
[282.02–286.32] the onboarding so that you kind of see like what are you getting into what are you going to be
[286.32–289.96] under written for what are you going to get covered for like what’s going to be the pricing
[289.96–294.66] so that we collect the right type of data right and that we can actually get you the right
[294.66–300.98] quotes and then once you get the policy then you get kind of the whole post-sales journey
[300.98–306.12] also powered by by AI what does it mean like on the background we have also the pricing
[306.12–310.76] which I was just mentioning we have the underwriting covered by AI we have also the the
[310.76–317.08] fraud detection right so we are able to be super accurate about giving you the best price and the
[317.08–323.84] best coverage ever interesting um curious to get your thoughts on this kind of emerging
[324.52–331.98] kind of trend if you like around personal agents you know grokbot dots muse these things
[331.98–337.30] have been kind of released fairly recently you know we had claw open claw before it where you
[337.30–343.32] know there is an emerging group of people that have their own personal agents and those agents
[343.32–347.52] are going to be the ones going out and getting renewing their insurance or making the
[347.52–352.06] claims on their behalf and stuff like that um obviously it’s early days for that but the
[352.06–356.34] evidence I’m seeing so far is that businesses are telling us that actually we get interactions
[356.34–361.86] like that how are you thinking about that in terms of as a business this emerging thing is
[362.50–367.76] what’s kind of going through your mind definitely it’s happening it’s starting to kind of evolve
[367.76–371.76] and we need to recognize that more and more people are leveraging their own personal AI
[371.76–379.20] agents I can personally argue that AI agent can buy things but only a person can have a feeling
[379.20–384.98] or a troubled time where they actually need to claim like that that difficult day in their
[384.98–388.42] life like that’s what they are going to express and that’s where you’re going to speaking
[388.42–392.46] about the trust that you said that’s where we really want to be there right so speaking
[392.46–398.08] about the agents I think the landscape is going to shift in what the companies need to cover
[398.08–402.56] in terms of their distribution and how this service right what does it mean like the agent
[402.56–407.68] in itself doesn’t matter about ux that you have right they don’t matter about the website polish
[407.68–414.36] website they have you need to have like a very accurate apis with the machine possible language
[414.36–419.30] and the data that’s exposed to those those agents so that’s kind of a completely I would say a new
[419.30–424.50] landscape how to service those agents so that they can make the most informed decisions would
[424.50–431.76] that be a purchase or explanation etc going back to the trust of AI in general as a concept right
[431.76–437.40] I would argue that even if you were to employ an agent right now today maybe over time it will
[437.40–442.22] change and evolve the trust that you put in your own agent you’ll still like to verify the
[442.22–446.66] very end so maybe right now the agent what they can do they can search they can search like a
[446.66–451.22] number of insurance companies out there and see like what’s the price comparing to the coverage
[451.22–456.60] and etc and give you kind of the final recommendation based on what they have I think
[456.60–461.60] that’s gonna be the distribution game for sure like so that we can be there with the right
[461.60–466.52] pricing with the right with the right coverage but then also very much important what happens
[466.52–471.36] after that right how do we treat those customers how do they get the level of service that
[471.36–475.64] they deserve so in the time they actually need us so that we are there so I think that’s still
[475.64–481.14] gonna be heavy on that element of earning trust while actually they are with us so that I think
[481.14–485.42] those are kind of maybe two distinct journeys that we are yet to see like one is agentic
[485.42–490.30] buying at the very beginning and that’s also very I would say still questionable in a way
[490.30–495.92] what are you allowing agent to do like on whose behalf is it regulated or not so I think
[495.92–500.94] regulators today even are a little bit lagging behind and learning together with us
[500.94–505.20] you know what’s allowed how are we going to regulate the space and etc so I think
[505.20–511.26] we still have a fairly long runway there to go and learn right but I think that’s definitely
[511.26–516.32] a field that we are exploring. It’s interesting isn’t it because you know hearing you speak
[516.32–522.74] there it’s like yeah there’s like layers to it one is kind of like getting a presence in those
[522.74–527.74] agentic platforms if I’m doing a comparison I use Claude to go out there and scour the internet
[527.74–532.72] for all the best insurance deals give me them all on my plate sort of thing you want to be
[532.72–540.92] there at the same time then I might have mews or what have you go to a comparison website or
[540.92–546.78] lemonade’s website directly do some research on that or even actually go ahead and start getting
[546.78–551.92] me a quote or something and all that lot and then the level beyond that is that actually
[551.92–558.48] the agent makes has a live interaction either with one of your agents live agents or with one
[558.48–563.10] of your AI agents sort of thing it seems to me there’s kind of like levels to it and what
[563.10–567.26] you’re saying there in terms of like how do you authenticate how do you know that this is
[567.26–571.92] Cain’s agent or this is Bogdan’s agent like it seems early days but I mean this thing could
[571.92–576.70] we don’t know what chat gpt took off in a month so this stuff could potentially happen
[576.70–580.84] pretty quickly I mean it’s interesting to to figure it out. I agree with that and one can
[580.84–586.56] argue like what matters in the in that space right does empathy matter that do agents matter
[586.56–590.36] about the empathy or how they are treated or they matter about the pricing or they matter
[590.36–595.18] about the coverage like what elements would actually go in a buying decision right now if
[595.18–599.74] that will be an agent right like we know humans actually are buying based on their feelings
[599.74–604.64] and emotions more often than like on a rationale right one can argue like what’s what happens
[604.64–609.68] with the agent right how do they gonna buy like how are you gonna instruct your agent agent
[609.68–615.66] Cain to say hey my agent please buy because based on this set of criterias right so that’s
[615.66–619.44] going to be very interesting to see what are the buying decisions and criterias for those agents
[619.44–625.34] to do and I might not know why I buy as well and then secondly is you know businesses have
[625.34–630.34] spent a lot of time and effort and a hell of a lot of money competing on the experience layer
[630.34–636.90] so where you know insurance companies they all insure people so fundamentally at a fundamental
[636.90–640.50] level there’s a lot of similarities between insurance companies but everything we’ve been
[640.50–644.28] talking about here so far has been trust exactly that’s a differentiator for lemonade
[644.28–649.68] is the trust that we have the interactions we provide what happens to the interaction
[650.48–656.96] if the interaction is happening between my agent and an AI agent that lemonade provide does the
[656.96–661.68] interaction matter because the agents will probably just figure it out anyway you know it’s
[661.68–667.64] interesting yeah I would say like there is always going to be a downstream kind of to a certain level
[667.64–672.00] human element of that right so maybe the transaction will be closed at the beginning
[672.00–675.98] based on the best price the best coverage and etc but it’s going to be very important what
[675.98–681.06] happens also downstream and that’s what I’m trying to to put a focus on right now is what
[681.06–686.50] actually happens after right when you actually need like insurance tech companies
[686.50–690.82] are not traditional software companies right you don’t need to be tied to an app right
[690.82–696.54] you actually it’s a service oriented business right so you actually need to interact let’s say
[696.54–700.94] with a company when you need to download your policy right when you need to know to add someone
[700.94–705.24] else to your policy right when you need to clean something right so AI has been like
[705.24–712.38] significant help in providing for instance that level of safety like peace of mind so that you
[712.38–716.86] know that you are covered and you are actually going to be treated well when you need it let’s
[716.86–722.60] say you have a you have a pet right at your home and you are the veterinary and unfortunately you
[722.60–726.60] need to pay for something and you’re a cover for that that’s not the moment when you want to have
[726.60–733.42] a friction right and that’s when you earn trust with your customers right so again not not saying
[733.42–737.24] that it’s not important like how you compete on the upfront in the in the top of the funnel
[737.24–742.14] right when you say hey how my agent’s gonna treat like I think it’s a fairly big distribution
[742.14–747.76] game over there like how are we gonna be compared to the others basically AI will help us be a little
[747.76–752.40] bit more not a little bit more like way more precise for we cover how we cover right and then
[752.40–758.44] to which price elements or price points right but then very important what happens maybe because
[758.44–762.30] it’s close to my heart and I’m living that world like a post-sales world like optimizing that
[762.30–769.64] journey very important how you retain trust and even kind of continue having your lifetime
[769.64–774.82] customer if you will yeah I think the challenging part of insurance is that if you’re one of the
[774.82–780.30] customers who’s fortunate fortunate enough to not have to claim you probably have a worse
[780.30–786.94] relationship because if I do have to claim you have an opportunity now to really build that trust
[786.94–790.84] if I have a claim and it goes through so swimmingly and there’s no problem and I’m
[790.84–796.08] treat really really well and all that kind of thing the the chances of me saying well regardless
[796.08–800.18] of the price stops being a problem then yeah because the renewal is when I like the company
[800.18–805.52] and I trust the company so maybe it’s when I don’t have a problem that’s where the
[805.52–809.72] issue is because I might be more fickle then I’m just looking for a cheaper deal sort of thing
[809.72–815.58] so it’s you know where in that post-sale relationship can we build our trust it’s an
[815.58–820.92] interesting question true and again like just because our ability to work with the latest
[820.92–826.38] models with our latest language models as well as the machine learning models allows us to be
[826.38–831.02] even more precise for you like when it comes to let’s say for the renewal time right
[831.02–835.24] to be more precise be competitive with the market and give you the best price ever
[835.78–840.28] for the coverage that you need yeah brilliant brilliant well well done appreciate your time
[840.28–843.34] thank you so much thank you really appreciate it nice one thanks very much

Share

Weekly newsletter

The latest in AI-powered customer experience. Make better strategic decisions with the help of our weekly newsletter.

Host

Kane Simms

A strategic AI advisor who, for the past decade, has helped business leaders and product owners transform customer experience using conversational and generative AI.

Share

✓   Link copied

Weekly newsletter

The latest in AI-powered customer experience. Make better strategic decisions with the help of our weekly newsletter.

Top articles and podcasts

Related content

What it takes to make agentic AI work at scale
Michiel Kouijzer, SAFe Product Manager at Essent, shares the practical foundations behind customer-facing agentic AI.
Exclusive: Inside Automation Anywhere’s boost.ai acquisition plans
In this exclusive interview, we speak with Jerry Haywood, CEO of boost.ai, and Ankur Kothari, co-founder and COO of Automation Anywhere, about the proposed combination.
What does a good AI agent testing approach look like?
When is an AI agent ready to go live? Discover how development testing, stress testing and clear pass/fail criteria help build confidence before deployment.
What does it take to make a voice AI agent reliable?
Rohan Vasishth, Co-founder and CEO of Bluejay, explains how to test voice AI agents and build trust for enterprise deployment.

Kill the IVR, keep the conversation - exclusive live webinar, November 10

Meet VUX at CCW Europe, Amsterdam, October 5-7

Register now: Why your contact centre playbook is obsolete